Contractor's Tools
IR35 News
Recruiter FAQs

Are you switching from Limited Company to Umbrella Employment? Click here to calculate your take home pay >>

We have created an information hub to support our Orange Genie Accountancy clients, our Umbrella Employees and agencies where the Covid-19 rules and legislation are explained for recruiters, contractors and the self-employed. Click here to find out more>>

Is Umbrella Company Employment the Best Option for You?

Umbrella Company

Even if you’ve been contracting for a while, it’s worth checking that you’re still operating in the best way for you. After all, things change and you might make a different choice based on your current circumstances. In terms of how you operate as a contractor, you’re likely to have three options, agency PAYE, an umbrella company or running your own limited company. In this article we’ll look at all three, so you can check that you’re using the right one.

Orange Genie Umbrella or Agency PAYE? : Click here to download our free guide >>

Agency PAYE

This is where you’re employed directly by the agency, who will pay you through their own PAYE system for work you do for their client. Any tax and National Insurance contributions due on your income will be deducted by the agency when they pay you.  

You’ll be employed separately for each assignment, so you’ll have a new period of employment for each end client or agency that you work for. If you work as a contractor for any length of time this can make for a complicated CV, and difficulty obtaining references or credit.

You may be engaged as a “worker” rather than an employee, which means you don’t have access to full employment rights, and certainly anything that relies on length of service is unlikely to apply. The engagement terminates at the end of each assignment, so while you’re not working you have no rights at all, even if you intend to continue working for the same agency.

Generally, agency PAYE is only suitable for workers who don’t intend to continue contracting for very long, for example if you’re starting a new job on a temp to perm basis, or you’re contracting as a stop-gap between permanent roles. If you intend to continue contracting for any length of time, or if you’re likely to complete a succession of different assignments, you’ll almost certainly be better off with one of the other two options.

Umbrella company employment

As the name suggests, if you choose this option, you’ll be employed by an umbrella company, who will supply your services to the agency. The agency will pay the umbrella company for the work you do for their client, and the umbrella company will pay you as their employee. Again, any tax or NICs due on your employment income will be deducted by the umbrella company when they pay you.

You can expect to be paid roughly the same through an umbrella company as you will through agency PAYE, but umbrella employment has some important advantages.

Continuous employment

You’ll be an employee of the umbrella company, rather than a “worker”, which means you’ll have all the rights that UK law affords to employees.

Also, because you’re employed by the umbrella company rather than the agency, your employment doesn’t end when your assignment ends. You’ll have a single, continuous employment across all your assignments, even if you work for many different clients or agencies. For credit and reference purposes you have one period of permanent employment from the day you join the umbrella to the day you leave them.

This means you have full employment rights, including sick pay, maternity/paternity pay, access to a workplace pension and paid holiday, and you retain these rights when you’re between assignments.

Additional benefits

If you’re lucky enough to be employed by Orange Genie, you’ll also have access to a range of additional benefits, designed with your experience as a contractor and your wellbeing in mind. All these benefits are available to you as our employee, at no cost to you:

Umbrella Company

Choosing the right umbrella company

Whichever umbrella company you choose, it’s important to make sure they’re accredited by the FCSA. This is the best way to ensure they are both competent and compliant, so your pay will be correct and you won’t end up with a huge tax bill because they did something wrong. As well as ensuring they’re accredited, we’d also advise you to ask for full details of everything they offer their employees. This will tell you how much they value their employees, and how well they’ll look after you and your interests.

Limited company

The third option is to trade through your own limited company. Your company would have a contract with the agency to supply your services, and the agency would pay your company for the work you complete for their client. As a director and shareholder, you would then have a choice about how you pay yourself, and by using a combination of salary and dividends you can legitimately minimise your tax liability.

Trading through your own limited company is the most tax efficient option for some contractors, but the advantages are only available in the right circumstances. We’d advise you to check carefully to make sure this route is right for you, before deciding to “go limited”. Here are some things to consider:

Will you be inside or outside IR35?

IR35 is legislation designed to prevent “disguised employees” benefitting from the tax advantages of trading through a limited company. An IR35 assessment will look at your contract and working practices to determine whether you’re operating like an employee, or if you’re legitimately in business for yourself. If you’re operating like an employee, or “inside IR35”, you’ll have to pay tax on your contract rate as if it was employment income. Many contractors find that they’re better off with umbrella employment if they’re inside IR35.

If you’re working on a public-sector contract, the end client is responsible for assessing your IR35 status. On private-sector contracts, you are responsible for assessing your own status, for now. From April 2021, the public-sector rules will be extended to include the private-sector.

Some roles are very unlikely to fall outside IR35. For example, supply teachers and agency nurses are likely to be better off with umbrella employment.

How much is your contract rate?

Trading through your own limited company is much more advantageous to high-earning contractors who will get more value from the associated tax-planning opportunities. Generally, we’d recommend the limited option to contractors earning a rate of £150/day or more.

Does this sound like you?

If your contract rate is usually £150/day or more, you usually work outside IR35 and you’ re happy completing a small amount of administration using an online software package, you may be better off trading through your own limited company. Our expert team will be happy to discuss this with you in detail.

If you have any questions or if we can help in any way, please contact us on 01296 468 483 or email or use our Limited VS Umbrella assessment tool



Request a Call Back


edge promo